Uncategorized

Sex and Religion

Does Islam make people radical or is it peaceful?

Are religious people loving and nice or stern and interfering?

Does religion make people better or worse?

Lots of people offer answers to these questions, and probably even more people wonder what the answers are.  However, it is hard to get hard data about religion with which to answer them.

To see why, consider the analogy with sex. Suppose I wanted to know about how my sex life is going and I scanned the t.v. offerings and found a show where people went on it and talked honestly about their sex lives.   I could find the answers to questions like: how?  with who?  in what fashion?  with what tempo?  with what addition?   with what subtraction?  by dint of what?  in sufferance of how?  when?  where?   The different answers the participants of the show gave to these questions  would be good and helpful data, wouldn’t it?

No.

Because all these people would share a single peculiarity which makes them an unrepresentative sample.  Whatever unusual peculiarities or quirks they are willing to talk about there is a single peculiarity that unites them that goes deeper than all the rest:

They are willing to go on a television show and talk about their sex lives.

If I decided to take their advice I would be taking advice that is actually pitched to a very particular fetishistic subculture of exhibitionists as something that applied to me.

One could say in a sense that the moment I watched the television show I was changing my sexuality into an exhibitionist/voyeuristic variety.  In the effort to inform myself I would be changing myself.

Or perhaps even more accurately the moment I decided that sex was the sort of thing I needed to be informed about I would have taken the decisive step towards voyeurism.

I wager someone could make a similar argument about religion!

Advertisements
Standard

7 thoughts on “Sex and Religion

  1. Not exactly… Religions are based on Holy Books, and although they are all up for interpretation, there a limit as to how much you can bend what it says.

    Or to put it differently, when you look at the text (of any religion) and then you hear people (followers) talk about it, you can very quickly see who’s being overly apologetic and who’s not…

  2. Mikey says:

    An experiment I’ve tried once or twice is to ask Christians what the essential thing is which makes someone a Christian or not a Christian. Most people feel they know the answer and that they should be able to give one reasonably quickly, but also, unless they confer, two people from the same church are unlikely to give the same answer.

    So I guess my point is that religion, what it means, what effect it has, how it is used, how important it is, will vary a lot from person to person. Or, possibly, people just find it hard to think of essential properties or the question’s bullshit in the first place.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s